Chinese School - Uphold both the law and compasssion

Opinion / Zou Hanru

Uphold both the law and compasssion
By Zou Hanru (China Daily)
Updated: 2006-06-09 06:48

Selling or buying sex is illegal in China. But the punishments meted out
by police vary in different parts of the country. Sometimes, offenders
are locked up for a couple of days or are fined. Some could end up facing
both penalties.

To rule out such discrepancies in law enforcement, police authorities in
East China's Jiangsu Province have come up with a set of guidelines on
how to handle prostitution and related cases.

Lenient penalties of no more than five days' detention or a maximum fine
of 500 yuan (US$62.5) have been suggested for first-time offenders and
those forced into prostitution by poverty.

But this "poverty clause" has proven controversial, with debates raging
in the mass media and on the Internet. Those supporting the proposal were
delighted to see an element of compassion introduced to criminal law
enforcement, while opponents question the malleability of the law.

But it's pretty safe to assume that most of us would agree that a society
is best governed by a balanced combination of law and compassion.

Criminal law enforcement is perhaps the only area designed purposefully
by the government to inflict pain on offenders. The severity of the
punishment has to match the seriousness of the crime, regardless of an
offender's sex, race or socio-economic status. That is to say that if a
society wishes to have lasting stability, it has to ensure that all are
equal before its laws. Being rich or poor should not make any difference.
Only an equal and full application of criminal law can deter crime, the
ultimate goal that criminal law enforcement is meant to achieve.

Technically speaking, the "poverty clause" doesn't seem practical. What
exactly is the "poverty line" that will qualify sex workers for such
lenient treatment? If there is one, is it uniform? Prostitutes flock to
Jiangsu from all over the country and there is a wide gap in the
household incomes of not only people living in urban and rural areas, but
also between those in East China's coastal region and those in the
underdeveloped western region. In addition, which government agency is
authoritative enough to substantiate an offender's poverty claim? Until
all of these questions and many more are given proper answers, such a
scheme could be open to abuse.

A society without the rule of law is bound to descend into chaos. But a
society without compassion is also unpalatable. Apart from law
enforcement, there are plenty of ways people can empathize with the
disadvantaged and marginalized.

Let's take a look at how an outreach group in Shanghai works to protect
the health of the city's sex workers.

Based on the understanding that a police crackdown on prostitution will
not stop the spread of AIDS and venereal diseases, and would only drive
this unsavoury trade deeper underground, disease-control workers in
Changning District, Shanghai, have tried a different approach help
instead of hunt.

Under a "peer education" programme launched in April, the outreach group
invited representatives from more than 1,000 barbers' shops many of which
operate as fronts for brothels to attend lectures on AIDS and venereal
diseases. They were also taught the correct way to use a condom and urged
never to accept requests for condom-free sex. They are then expected to
spread this information among their peers. The programme has had a
difficult start, as prostitutes are hard to reach and tend to shy away
from the authorities. It took off in earnest only after they realized
that the group was indeed there to help, instead of hunting them down.

Women are forced to sell their bodies for different reasons. Poverty and
unemployment are just two of them. An iron-fisted approach alone is not
going to wipe out prostitution. For that, the government needs to involve
the entire community in joint efforts to protect prostitutes' rights and
give them opportunities.

A "harmonious society" can only exist when both law and compassion are
upheld.

Email: zouhr@chinadaily.com.cn

(China Daily 06/09/2006 page4)

Hot Talks

� Share Our Crafts: Naming contest

� The microprints of 1980s Shanghai

� The ceremony at the White House

� Do teenagers really need mobiles?

� China's Serious Environment Problem

Most Commented/Read Stories in 48 Hours

Alibaba is the largest B2B marketplace in the world. Source model ship,
wooden puzzle, one-piece toilet, RC hovercraft, photo album, prom dress,
pocket bike, Vaginal Speculum, Samurai Sword, String Panty and PVC Pipe.

Learn Chinese, Free Chinese Lesson, Learning Materials, Mandarin audio lessons, Chinese writing lessons, Chinese vocabulary lists, About chinese characters, News in Chinese, Go to China, Travel to China, Study in China, Teach in China, Dictionaries, Learn Chinese Painting, Your name in Chinese, Chinese calligraphy, Chinese songs, Chinese proverbs, Chinese poetry, Chinese tattoo, Beijing 2008 Olympics, Mandarin Phrasebook, Chinese editor, Pinyin editor, China Travel, Travel to Beijing, Travel to Tibet